Ohio families say 250 trees meant to shield their homes from coal-ash ponds were cut down during demolition of a power plant; a jury has now awarded the neighbours $1.65 million for the lost buffer
US company cuts down protected trees in violation of greenbelt agreement.

A US jury has awarded $1.65 million to a group of Ohio residents after hundreds of trees that formed a protective greenbelt around their homes were cut down during the demolition of a former coal-fired power plant.The residents of Pierce Township had sued Commercial Liability Partners (CLP), the company that bought the 1,443-acre site of the former William C. Beckjord power plant from Duke Energy in 2018. They alleged that the company violated an agreement to preserve the greenbelt, which was meant to separate nearby homes from coal-ash ponds along the Ohio River.According to WCPO, the jury announced its verdict on Wednesday after deliberating for around two-and-a-half hours. It awarded the residents $1,654,080 to compensate for the destruction of trees and fund restoration of the forest.The lawsuit was filed in 2019 by Neighbors Opposing Pit Expansion (NOPE), a local residents’ group. The organisation had sought $3.3 million in damages, arguing that the loss of the trees had damaged the greenbelt and affected the surrounding environment.

Residents said logging destroyed decades-old greenbelt

Residents told the court that bulldozers and logging trucks had cut through the mature forest, removing around 250 trees, including pine, walnut, cherry and maple varieties. Some of the trees had grown as tall as 50 feet.They said the logging left deep tracks in the forest, destroyed vegetation and changed the character of the area. Residents also reported a decline in wildlife and birds, while invasive honeysuckle spread across parts of the land.Pierce Township Board of Trustees Chairman Allen Freeman said the tree line had been visibly cut down after CLP took ownership of the property in 2018.The residents argued that the greenbelt was protected under a 1986 agreement between the local community and the then-owner, Cincinnati Gas & Electric. The agreement required the preservation of the buffer as a “substantially undisturbed” area.They also said the trees and their root systems helped stabilise the hillsides around the coal-ash ponds, while shielding homes from the view of the waste-storage site.CLP disputed the residents’ claims and questioned the amount of compensation they were seeking. Its lawyer argued that there were no photographs showing the condition of the greenbelt before the logging and described the $3.3 million demand as unreasonable.

Jury awards money for tree replacement and forest restoration

Experts presented competing estimates of the damage and the cost of restoring the greenbelt during the trial.A tree expert called by CLP suggested that the residents should receive no compensation for the large trees that had been cut down. He estimated that planting seedlings in the 17-acre greenbelt would cost around $25,000, arguing that the area was already recovering.However, an expert representing NOPE estimated that restoring the forest and removing invasive honeysuckle would cost approximately $500,000. He also valued the loss of the trees at around $2.7 million, saying the logging had damaged the forest’s canopy and compacted the soil.The jury ultimately awarded $1,142,860 for replacing 233 trees, $102,000 to remove invasive species, $28,600 for revegetating the land and $160,620 for caring for the newly planted saplings.The Beckjord power plant, built in the 1950s, was shut down by Duke Energy in 2014. More than five million tons of coal ash were stored in unlined, man-made ponds at the site near the Ohio River.Coal ash is the residue left after coal is burned to generate electricity. It can contain toxic heavy metals, including mercury, cadmium and arsenic, which can threaten groundwater, soil and rivers.The coal-ash ponds are close to the Ohio River, a drinking-water source for millions of people in the Greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky regions. The waste-storage site is also near Clermont County’s public drinking-water wells.A separate part of the dispute, involving allegations that CLP failed to disclose information about the handling and movement of coal ash, is yet to go before another jury. Clermont County has also filed a separate lawsuit seeking to force companies linked to the site to clean up the waste.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *