NEW DELHI: Supreme Court Tuesday upheld Allahabad HC’s order staying the conviction of SP neta Azam Khan in a case relating to the forgery of a birth certificate and granted the same relief to Khan’s son and wife, who were denied this benefit by the high court.A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu said all three were on the same footing and questioned the HC for discriminating among them. It said there was “apparent legal dichotomy in the judgement”. It said, “We find that the HC failed to articulate any coherent legal reason why similar relief, as granted to Mohammad Azam Khan, was denied, even though all three were convicted under the self-same charge of conspiracy.
““Where several convicts standing on the same footing seek stay/suspension of conviction, it is legitimate for them to expect similar treatment… Parity being a facet of Article 14 of Constitution, equals ought to be treated equally unless, of course, an intelligible differentia having a rational nexus with the object of the order distinguishes one from the others,” the bench said.SC said though differential treatment was not forbidden, “an unreasoned differential treatment cannot be sustained”. It said, “If the court grants a stay/suspension of conviction to one… while similar relief to other similarly situated convicts is denied, the distinguishing feature on the record must be identified and expressly stated as the reason for the departure from parity. An order silent on that point is, by itself, arbitrary.“