A Hudson homeowner spent months criticising the city’s council president, Christopher Foster, at public meetings. The council president sued him for defamation. On Thursday, 12 November, the Ninth District Court of Appeals in Summit County overturned a lower court’s ruling on Ravida’s request to end the case early. The lower court had not explained its reasoning clearly enough for the appeals court to review. The case now goes back for a more detailed decision, and the question of whether Ravida’s words were defamatory remains unanswered.
A fence dispute that started it all
The dispute began in 2023, when Anthony Ravida, a Hudson homeowner, asked the city for permission to build a fence. The fence he built did not meet the city’s codes, and he refused to fix it. A jury later convicted him of a zoning violation, and he appealed. While the appeal was pending, he began attending council meetings and using the public comment period to talk about his case. During meetings in early 2025, the homeowner stated that his conviction for violating the zoning code was based on a “false narrative” created by the city manager and council president. The homeowner also claimed that Foster was “basically above the law”, as the council president had the city repair his driveway without a permit. By May, he was calling for Foster to be suspended, investigated by the state attorney general and possibly removed from office. He also called him corrupt.The council president defended the city’s actions on the record. Foster stated that Ravida’s fence plainly violated zoning rules. He also responded to the homeowner’s allegations: “Yeah, simple issues, blown into conspiracy theories about taking bribes, getting kickbacks from people for putting sidewalks around the community really is pretty sad but I appreciate you coming out here and straightening that out. ” The city manager said the driveway work was an emergency repair following a sinkhole in the public right of way. A construction company owner later told the council that a combination of personal circumstances and miscommunication had led to the permit being missed, and she denied any intentional wrongdoing.
The defamation suit
In May 2025, the council president filed a civil complaint against the homeowner, alleging defamation and false light invasion of privacy. The homeowner asked a judge to dismiss the case under Ohio’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, a law that took effect on 9 April 2025. The law is intended to protect people from expensive lawsuits over their speech on public matters. The trial court said the law applied only to statements made after the Act came into effect. It dismissed claims based on name-calling, such as calling Foster a liar or a thief, ruling that these were opinions. It retained claims based on accusations of bribery and fraud, finding that factual disputes remained to be resolved. For statements made before 9 April, the court did not apply the new law at all.
Appeals court calls for reconsideration
The appeals court reversed the lower court’s ruling, finding that it had not properly applied Ohio’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA). The trial court had applied the law only to statements the homeowner made after 9 April 2025, even though Foster had filed the lawsuit after that date. The appeals court also said the lower court had not properly explained its decision or addressed the arguments made by both sides. It sent the case back for “a sufficiently detailed judgment entry” that would allow meaningful review.The appeals court also said the trial court was wrong to exclude the earlier statements. The lawsuit was filed after 9 April, and the law states that it applies to civil actions filed on or after that date.The appeals court did not decide whether the homeowner’s statements were defamatory. That question still needs to be examined by the trial court. The appeals court’s ruling was supported by two judges, while the third agreed with the judgment but not the reasoning. The case now returns to the trial court.